I'm trying to install XP on a SATA rack drive and having problems. I've disconnected all other hard drives, put in the XP disc and booted up fine....it sees the XP disc and starts the setup process. It continues to copy files and then has to do a reboot. Upon reboot, I get the message, "A disk read error occurred Press Ctrl+Alt+Del to restart". Of course doing this just makes the same thing happen. The disc is a 320 GB drive with a 45 gb OS partition that's formatted NTFS and clean.
I've done the same process in other drives with Linux OS's and Windows 7 beta with no problems and wonder why this XP install is not working. The BIOS sees the SATA drive and even booting directly to the drive doesn't work. I can put in any other drive in the rack and boot directly to it with no problems.
Any ideas and am I even making sense?
TIA

During the install process there is a point where you can install drivers (Press F6).
Did you install the SATA drivers?

JS
http://www.pagestart.com

"Paul " <pcostanza@cox.net> wrote in message news:3438E7E1-3A9C-4EFC-9ECA-87D55B02D986@microsoft.com...
I'm trying to install XP on a SATA rack drive and having problems. I've disconnected all other hard drives, put in the XP disc and booted up fine....it sees the XP disc and starts the setup process. It continues to copy files and then has to do a reboot. Upon reboot, I get the message, "A disk read error occurred Press Ctrl+Alt+Del to restart". Of course doing this just makes the same thing happen. The disc is a 320 GB drive with a 45 gb OS partition that's formatted NTFS and clean.
I've done the same process in other drives with Linux OS's and Windows 7 beta with no problems and wonder why this XP install is not working. The BIOS sees the SATA drive and even booting directly to the drive doesn't work. I can put in any other drive in the rack and boot directly to it with no problems.
Any ideas and am I even making sense?
TIA

No, did not but I've never had to before.....I'll give that a go and see if it works. I'll feel awfully stupid if that's the case.
thanks
"JS" <@> wrote in message news:egk5LI7WJHA.5476@TK2MSFTNGP03.phx.gbl...
During the install process there is a point where you can install drivers (Press F6).
Did you install the SATA drivers?

JS
http://www.pagestart.com

"Paul " <pcostanza@cox.net> wrote in message news:3438E7E1-3A9C-4EFC-9ECA-87D55B02D986@microsoft.com...
I'm trying to install XP on a SATA rack drive and having problems. I've disconnected all other hard drives, put in the XP disc and booted up fine....it sees the XP disc and starts the setup process. It continues to copy files and then has to do a reboot. Upon reboot, I get the message, "A disk read error occurred Press Ctrl+Alt+Del to restart". Of course doing this just makes the same thing happen. The disc is a 320 GB drive with a 45 gb OS partition that's formatted NTFS and clean.
I've done the same process in other drives with Linux OS's and Windows 7 beta with no problems and wonder why this XP install is not working. The BIOS sees the SATA drive and even booting directly to the drive doesn't work. I can put in any other drive in the rack and boot directly to it with no problems.
Any ideas and am I even making sense?
TIA

"Paul " <pcostanza@cox.net> wrote in message
news:3438E7E1-3A9C-4EFC-9ECA-87D55B02D986@microsoft.com...
I'm trying to install XP on a SATA rack drive and having problems. I've
disconnected all other hard drives, put in the XP disc and booted up
fine....it sees the XP disc and starts the setup process. It continues to
copy files and then has to do a reboot. Upon reboot, I get the message, "A
disk read error occurred Press Ctrl+Alt+Del to restart". Of course doing
this just makes the same thing happen. The disc is a 320 GB drive with a 45
gb OS partition that's formatted NTFS and clean.
I've done the same process in other drives with Linux OS's and Windows 7
beta with no problems and wonder why this XP install is not working. The
BIOS sees the SATA drive and even booting directly to the drive doesn't
work. I can put in any other drive in the rack and boot directly to it with
no problems.
Any ideas and am I even making sense?
TIA


"JS" <@> wrote in message news:egk5LI7WJHA.5476@TK2MSFTNGP03.phx.gbl...
During the install process there is a point where you can install drivers
(Press F6).
Did you install the SATA drivers?
JS
http://www.pagestart.com



"Paul " <pcostanza@cox.net> wrote in message
news:C118E474-166D-49EF-890F-325692407ADD@microsoft.com...
No, did not but I've never had to before.....I'll give that a go and see if
it works. I'll feel awfully stupid if that's the case.
thanks


Paul:
I really don't think this is a SATA controller driver issue since you've
indicated you're able to at least begin the XP OS setup process. If it *was*
a SATA driver issue you would have rec'd a message that Setup could not
detect a HDD at the very beginning of the setup process and you would have
had to abort at that point.

I assume the "SATA rack drive" you're referring to is a removable HDD mobile
rack affair, right?

You're absolutely sure the problem SATA HDD has been correctly installed in
the removable tray of the rack? We'll assume it is since you say there's no
problem with another HDD in the same mobile rack.

And you've also indicated that you've installed the problem disk as an
internal HDD but that you still get that same error message during the XP
install, right?

You've indicated that the problem HDD is multi-partitioned. How did you
accomplish that? Through Disk Management using your other boot drive?

What happens if you install the problem HDD as a secondary HDD in your
system, using your other HDD as the boot drive and accessing Disk
Management? The secondary HDD is seen OK? If so, think it might be wise to
delete all partitions and then start over with trying a fresh install of the
OS with the disk in its mobile rack and again, if no go there, try
connecting it again internally?

Although it doesn't sound like a defective HDD problem it might still be a
good idea to check out the disk with a HDD diagnostic utility from the
disk's manuf.
Anna

It ended up being the XP Pro disc I was using. Don't know why but I tried
another one to install and it worked right away and things are fine. No
SATA drivers needed.

Thanks for the help.

"Anna" <myname@myisp.net> wrote in message
news:uEpbhe8WJHA.3808@TK2MSFTNGP05.phx.gbl...
>
>
> "Paul " <pcostanza@cox.net> wrote in message
> news:3438E7E1-3A9C-4EFC-9ECA-87D55B02D986@microsoft.com...
> I'm trying to install XP on a SATA rack drive and having problems.
> I've disconnected all other hard drives, put in the XP disc and booted up
> fine....it sees the XP disc and starts the setup process. It continues to
> copy files and then has to do a reboot. Upon reboot, I get the message,
> "A disk read error occurred Press Ctrl+Alt+Del to restart". Of course
> doing this just makes the same thing happen. The disc is a 320 GB drive
> with a 45 gb OS partition that's formatted NTFS and clean.
> I've done the same process in other drives with Linux OS's and Windows
> 7 beta with no problems and wonder why this XP install is not working.
> The BIOS sees the SATA drive and even booting directly to the drive
> doesn't work. I can put in any other drive in the rack and boot directly
> to it with no problems.
> Any ideas and am I even making sense?
> TIA
>
>
> "JS" <@> wrote in message news:egk5LI7WJHA.5476@TK2MSFTNGP03.phx.gbl...
> During the install process there is a point where you can install drivers
> (Press F6).
> Did you install the SATA drivers?
> JS
> http://www.pagestart.com
>
>
>
> "Paul " <pcostanza@cox.net> wrote in message
> news:C118E474-166D-49EF-890F-325692407ADD@microsoft.com...
> No, did not but I've never had to before.....I'll give that a go and see
> if it works. I'll feel awfully stupid if that's the case.
> thanks
>
>
> Paul:
> I really don't think this is a SATA controller driver issue since you've
> indicated you're able to at least begin the XP OS setup process. If it
> *was* a SATA driver issue you would have rec'd a message that Setup could
> not detect a HDD at the very beginning of the setup process and you would
> have had to abort at that point.
>
> I assume the "SATA rack drive" you're referring to is a removable HDD
> mobile rack affair, right?
>
> You're absolutely sure the problem SATA HDD has been correctly installed
> in the removable tray of the rack? We'll assume it is since you say
> there's no problem with another HDD in the same mobile rack.
>
> And you've also indicated that you've installed the problem disk as an
> internal HDD but that you still get that same error message during the XP
> install, right?
>
> You've indicated that the problem HDD is multi-partitioned. How did you
> accomplish that? Through Disk Management using your other boot drive?
>
> What happens if you install the problem HDD as a secondary HDD in your
> system, using your other HDD as the boot drive and accessing Disk
> Management? The secondary HDD is seen OK? If so, think it might be wise to
> delete all partitions and then start over with trying a fresh install of
> the OS with the disk in its mobile rack and again, if no go there, try
> connecting it again internally?
>
> Although it doesn't sound like a defective HDD problem it might still be a
> good idea to check out the disk with a HDD diagnostic utility from the
> disk's manuf.
> Anna
>

Paul wrote:
> It ended up being the XP Pro disc I was using. Don't know why but I
> tried another one to install and it worked right away and things are
> fine. No SATA drivers needed.
>
> Thanks for the help.

Did the one that worked have either SP2 or SP3?

Alias
>
> "Anna" <myname@myisp.net> wrote in message
> news:uEpbhe8WJHA.3808@TK2MSFTNGP05.phx.gbl...
>>
>>
>> "Paul " <pcostanza@cox.net> wrote in message
>> news:3438E7E1-3A9C-4EFC-9ECA-87D55B02D986@microsoft.com...
>> I'm trying to install XP on a SATA rack drive and having problems.
>> I've disconnected all other hard drives, put in the XP disc and booted
>> up fine....it sees the XP disc and starts the setup process. It
>> continues to copy files and then has to do a reboot. Upon reboot, I
>> get the message, "A disk read error occurred Press Ctrl+Alt+Del to
>> restart". Of course doing this just makes the same thing happen. The
>> disc is a 320 GB drive with a 45 gb OS partition that's formatted NTFS
>> and clean.
>> I've done the same process in other drives with Linux OS's and
>> Windows 7 beta with no problems and wonder why this XP install is not
>> working. The BIOS sees the SATA drive and even booting directly to the
>> drive doesn't work. I can put in any other drive in the rack and boot
>> directly to it with no problems.
>> Any ideas and am I even making sense?
>> TIA
>>
>>
>> "JS" <@> wrote in message news:egk5LI7WJHA.5476@TK2MSFTNGP03.phx.gbl...
>> During the install process there is a point where you can install
>> drivers (Press F6).
>> Did you install the SATA drivers?
>> JS
>> http://www.pagestart.com
>>
>>
>>
>> "Paul " <pcostanza@cox.net> wrote in message
>> news:C118E474-166D-49EF-890F-325692407ADD@microsoft.com...
>> No, did not but I've never had to before.....I'll give that a go and
>> see if it works. I'll feel awfully stupid if that's the case.
>> thanks
>>
>>
>> Paul:
>> I really don't think this is a SATA controller driver issue since
>> you've indicated you're able to at least begin the XP OS setup
>> process. If it *was* a SATA driver issue you would have rec'd a
>> message that Setup could not detect a HDD at the very beginning of the
>> setup process and you would have had to abort at that point.
>>
>> I assume the "SATA rack drive" you're referring to is a removable HDD
>> mobile rack affair, right?
>>
>> You're absolutely sure the problem SATA HDD has been correctly
>> installed in the removable tray of the rack? We'll assume it is since
>> you say there's no problem with another HDD in the same mobile rack.
>>
>> And you've also indicated that you've installed the problem disk as an
>> internal HDD but that you still get that same error message during the
>> XP install, right?
>>
>> You've indicated that the problem HDD is multi-partitioned. How did
>> you accomplish that? Through Disk Management using your other boot drive?
>>
>> What happens if you install the problem HDD as a secondary HDD in your
>> system, using your other HDD as the boot drive and accessing Disk
>> Management? The secondary HDD is seen OK? If so, think it might be
>> wise to delete all partitions and then start over with trying a fresh
>> install of the OS with the disk in its mobile rack and again, if no go
>> there, try connecting it again internally?
>>
>> Although it doesn't sound like a defective HDD problem it might still
>> be a good idea to check out the disk with a HDD diagnostic utility
>> from the disk's manuf.
>> Anna
>>

Turns out it was a bad XP install disc. I tried another one and it worked
right away.
Thanks for the help.

Paul

"Anna" <myname@myisp.net> wrote in message
news:uEpbhe8WJHA.3808@TK2MSFTNGP05.phx.gbl...
>
>
> "Paul " <pcostanza@cox.net> wrote in message
> news:3438E7E1-3A9C-4EFC-9ECA-87D55B02D986@microsoft.com...
> I'm trying to install XP on a SATA rack drive and having problems.
> I've disconnected all other hard drives, put in the XP disc and booted up
> fine....it sees the XP disc and starts the setup process. It continues to
> copy files and then has to do a reboot. Upon reboot, I get the message,
> "A disk read error occurred Press Ctrl+Alt+Del to restart". Of course
> doing this just makes the same thing happen. The disc is a 320 GB drive
> with a 45 gb OS partition that's formatted NTFS and clean.
> I've done the same process in other drives with Linux OS's and Windows
> 7 beta with no problems and wonder why this XP install is not working.
> The BIOS sees the SATA drive and even booting directly to the drive
> doesn't work. I can put in any other drive in the rack and boot directly
> to it with no problems.
> Any ideas and am I even making sense?
> TIA
>
>
> "JS" <@> wrote in message news:egk5LI7WJHA.5476@TK2MSFTNGP03.phx.gbl...
> During the install process there is a point where you can install drivers
> (Press F6).
> Did you install the SATA drivers?
> JS
> http://www.pagestart.com
>
>
>
> "Paul " <pcostanza@cox.net> wrote in message
> news:C118E474-166D-49EF-890F-325692407ADD@microsoft.com...
> No, did not but I've never had to before.....I'll give that a go and see
> if it works. I'll feel awfully stupid if that's the case.
> thanks
>
>
> Paul:
> I really don't think this is a SATA controller driver issue since you've
> indicated you're able to at least begin the XP OS setup process. If it
> *was* a SATA driver issue you would have rec'd a message that Setup could
> not detect a HDD at the very beginning of the setup process and you would
> have had to abort at that point.
>
> I assume the "SATA rack drive" you're referring to is a removable HDD
> mobile rack affair, right?
>
> You're absolutely sure the problem SATA HDD has been correctly installed
> in the removable tray of the rack? We'll assume it is since you say
> there's no problem with another HDD in the same mobile rack.
>
> And you've also indicated that you've installed the problem disk as an
> internal HDD but that you still get that same error message during the XP
> install, right?
>
> You've indicated that the problem HDD is multi-partitioned. How did you
> accomplish that? Through Disk Management using your other boot drive?
>
> What happens if you install the problem HDD as a secondary HDD in your
> system, using your other HDD as the boot drive and accessing Disk
> Management? The secondary HDD is seen OK? If so, think it might be wise to
> delete all partitions and then start over with trying a fresh install of
> the OS with the disk in its mobile rack and again, if no go there, try
> connecting it again internally?
>
> Although it doesn't sound like a defective HDD problem it might still be a
> good idea to check out the disk with a HDD diagnostic utility from the
> disk's manuf.
> Anna
>