Problem -

On the day before thanksgiving my computer would not POST. I needed to pay
some bills online before leaving for vacation so in a panic I threw the HDD
into an old Socket A computer I had in the garage. I had to do a telephone
validation to reinstall XP on the drive with the new mobo and get the
computer to a point where I could get online to pay the bills. Now my good
computer (only a socket 462 but good in my eyes), the one I bought this XP
Pro OEM copy for, is POSTing fine and ready for action. All I had to do was
take out the memory sticks and blow the dust out of the DDR sockets. Wish I
knew then what I know now, oh well.

Here's the Question--- If I put the HDD and OEM license that was originally
registered to my good mobo/CPU/HDD back in that machine, will it work? Does
this comply with the EULA? Will another phone validation work? Or do I need
to buy a new OEM copy?

Below is some more background or just rambling...

I'm just confused because everyone says the OEM EULA doesn't allow use of
the license in a different computer but I did it. Now all I want is to go
back to how I was. Haven't tried yet. I was going to get another OEM copy and
HDD for the good computer and keep this tbird900 going for the kids, but wife
says no, I spend too much $ on computers and she is worried about kids
becoming "computer addicts", never saw the reason to build this one in 2003,
on and on... bartender... come down here...

My preferred option would be to go back to where I was 2 days before
thanksgiving - can I just reinstall this HDD and XP license back into the
good computer? Do the "windows licensing authorities" remember the HDD and
motherboard and CPU that are registered with this license, so I could do a
system restore from my external 500GB USB drive? I'm worried about messing
things up when I telephone validated my XP license to this old machine.

I could put the good PC in the boneyard and stay with this dinosaur, but the
trouble is it's running dog slow even for a tbird900 plus I am now having
problems which I suspect relate to me moving this OEM copy of XP to the old
computer. I've been doing updates all week, but now I can't get past the
Windows Installer 3.1 update. I tried all the applicable steps at
http://support.microsoft.com/kb/555175, but I get an Access Denied error
during this update, or it fails silently during the shutdown update. Plus I
can't get a couple security updates because the Genuine Advantage webpage
says my copy of XP cannot be validated due to "unknown error". Are these
enforcements against my moving the harddisk to an old computer in a jam?

An OEM licence is valid for the first PC its installed on, if that PC dies
so does the licence.
Changing a motherboard would require reactivation, unless maybe its
identical to the old
Puting your installation HD into a different PC should have required a
repair installation of winxp, you were lucky it worked, and lucky that MS
supplied activation key.
So if you put your HD back in its origonal PC your OEM Licence should be
still valid but will probably require reactivation.

"Mark Nelson" <MarkNelson@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in message
news:84B89836-884D-4ED4-BCFB-A46D89CC16CD@microsoft.com...
> Problem -
>
> On the day before thanksgiving my computer would not POST. I needed to pay
> some bills online before leaving for vacation so in a panic I threw the
> HDD
> into an old Socket A computer I had in the garage. I had to do a telephone
> validation to reinstall XP on the drive with the new mobo and get the
> computer to a point where I could get online to pay the bills. Now my good
> computer (only a socket 462 but good in my eyes), the one I bought this XP
> Pro OEM copy for, is POSTing fine and ready for action. All I had to do
> was
> take out the memory sticks and blow the dust out of the DDR sockets. Wish
> I
> knew then what I know now, oh well.
>
> Here's the Question--- If I put the HDD and OEM license that was
> originally
> registered to my good mobo/CPU/HDD back in that machine, will it work?
> Does
> this comply with the EULA? Will another phone validation work? Or do I
> need
> to buy a new OEM copy?
>
> Below is some more background or just rambling...
>
> I'm just confused because everyone says the OEM EULA doesn't allow use of
> the license in a different computer but I did it. Now all I want is to go
> back to how I was. Haven't tried yet. I was going to get another OEM copy
> and
> HDD for the good computer and keep this tbird900 going for the kids, but
> wife
> says no, I spend too much $ on computers and she is worried about kids
> becoming "computer addicts", never saw the reason to build this one in
> 2003,
> on and on... bartender... come down here...
>
> My preferred option would be to go back to where I was 2 days before
> thanksgiving - can I just reinstall this HDD and XP license back into the
> good computer? Do the "windows licensing authorities" remember the HDD and
> motherboard and CPU that are registered with this license, so I could do a
> system restore from my external 500GB USB drive? I'm worried about messing
> things up when I telephone validated my XP license to this old machine.
>
> I could put the good PC in the boneyard and stay with this dinosaur, but
> the
> trouble is it's running dog slow even for a tbird900 plus I am now having
> problems which I suspect relate to me moving this OEM copy of XP to the
> old
> computer. I've been doing updates all week, but now I can't get past the
> Windows Installer 3.1 update. I tried all the applicable steps at
> http://support.microsoft.com/kb/555175, but I get an Access Denied error
> during this update, or it fails silently during the shutdown update. Plus
> I
> can't get a couple security updates because the Genuine Advantage webpage
> says my copy of XP cannot be validated due to "unknown error". Are these
> enforcements against my moving the harddisk to an old computer in a jam?

On Thu, 29 Nov 2007 21:19:00 -0800, Mark Nelson
<MarkNelson@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote:

> Problem -
>
> On the day before thanksgiving my computer would not POST. I needed to pay
> some bills online before leaving for vacation so in a panic I threw the HDD
> into an old Socket A computer I had in the garage. I had to do a telephone
> validation to reinstall XP on the drive with the new mobo and get the
> computer to a point where I could get online to pay the bills. Now my good
> computer (only a socket 462 but good in my eyes), the one I bought this XP
> Pro OEM copy for, is POSTing fine and ready for action. All I had to do was
> take out the memory sticks and blow the dust out of the DDR sockets. Wish I
> knew then what I know now, oh well.
>
> Here's the Question--- If I put the HDD and OEM license that was originally
> registered to my good mobo/CPU/HDD back in that machine, will it work? Does
> this comply with the EULA?


Sorry, I'm lost here, and don't understand the question. Do you want
to use an OEM copy of Windows on a different machine from the one it
was originally installed on? If so, no, it does not comply with the
EULA.



> I'm just confused because everyone says the OEM EULA doesn't allow use of
> the license in a different computer


That's correct.


>but I did it.


What the EULA requires and what you can get away with are two
different things. Just because some people rob banks successfully
doesn't mean that it's therefore legal.

--
Ken Blake, Microsoft MVP Windows - Shell/User
Please Reply to the Newsgroup